Skip to content
Putters

4 Best Cleveland Golf Black Putters, Compared

Compare 4 Cleveland Golf black putters by specs. Find the best model for your stroke, including the top pick HB Soft 2 Black #11.

By FairGear Editorial Team

· 5 min read

4 Best Cleveland Golf Black Putters, Compared
Product image from the Amazon listing

As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.

Finding the best cleveland golf black putters requires matching your stroke to the right specs. We compared 4 models based on published listing data. The top pick is the Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black #11 Putter, 34". It leads because its single bend hosel supports left-handed straight stroke putters. This design helps you maintain consistent distance control. The other options offer different hosel styles and hand orientations. Use this guide to decide which putter fits your game.

Match your hand orientation to the hosel

Choose your putter based on your handedness and stroke path. Left-handed players with a straight stroke should select the HB Soft 2 Black #11 or the 34" Left Hand model. These feature oversized grips for stability. Right-handed golfers with straight or slight arc strokes should look at the Model 1 or the #10.5P. Both offer a 34-inch shaft length and plumber's neck design for consistent distance control.

#ProductBest forPrice
1Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black #11 Putter, 34" Best overallleft-handed straight stroke putters
2Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black 34" Putter Best budgetleft-handed golfers seeking stability
3Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 1 Putter Also greatStraight or slight arc stroke right-handers
4Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black #10.5P 34" Also greatstraight or slight arc stroke golfers

The best fit for you

  • You are a left-handed golfer with a straight stroke – Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black #11 Putter, 34" – The single bend hosel and oversized grip support consistent distance control.
  • You want a budget-friendly option for left-handed stability – Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black 34" Putter – The speed-optimized face and oversized grip provide reliable consistency for straight or slight arc strokes.
  • You are a right-handed player with a straight stroke – Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 1 Putter – This model offers a stable shaft feel for players preferring a 34-inch black putter.
  • You prefer a plumber's neck design for right-handed play – Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black #10.5P 34" – The specific hosel and shaft design target consistent distance control for straight or slight arc strokes.
1Best overall
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black #11 Putter, 34"

Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black #11 Putter, 34"

Best for: left-handed straight stroke putters

Color
Black
Hand Orientation
Left Hand
Club Length
34"
Hosel Type
Single Bend
Grip Type
Oversized
Shaft Length
34"

This Cleveland Golf HB Soft 2 Black Putter is a left-hand, single-bend model with a 34-inch length. It features an oversized grip and a 5-inch wide head. The face uses speed-optimized technology for consistent ball speed across a larger striking area. The shaft includes UST Mamiya All-In construction for stability. It is designed for straight or slight arc strokes, offering a specific toe hang and alignment system.

Pros
  • Speed-optimized face technology normalizes ball speed
  • UST Mamiya All-In shaft for stability
  • Oversized grip for enhanced feel
  • Designed for straight or slight arc strokes
Cons
  • Left hand orientation limits right-handed buyers
  • Single bend hosel restricts stroke type options
  • 34-inch length is shorter than 35-inch variants
Good fit if
  • You use a left hand
  • You prefer a straight putting stroke
  • You want a single bend hosel
Skip if
  • You are right-handed
  • You need a slant neck hosel
  • You prefer a 35-inch length

Verdict: Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black Putter 34" fits left-handed golfers who prefer a straight stroke and a single bend hosel. The oversized grip and specific alignment system support consistent distance control.

2Best budget
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black 34" Putter

Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black 34" Putter

Best for: left-handed golfers seeking stability

Color
Black
Hand Orientation
Left Hand
Club Length
34"
Hosel Type
Single Bend
Grip Type
Oversized
Shaft Length
34"

This Cleveland Golf HB Soft 2 Black putter is designed for left-handed players. It features a 34-inch single bend shaft and an oversized grip. The face uses Speed Optimized Technology to normalize ball speed across a larger striking area. The model includes a 20g weight in the butt end for consistent swing feel. It suits golfers seeking a straight or slight arc stroke profile with enhanced stability.

Pros
  • Speed Optimized Face Technology normalizes ball speed for consistent distance
  • Oversized grip provides enhanced stability and control
  • 20g weight in the butt end ensures consistent swing feel
  • Designed for straight or slight arc stroke types
Cons
  • Limited to left-hand orientation only
  • Single bend hosel restricts toe hang options
  • Oversized grip may feel too large for small hands
Good fit if
  • You are a left-handed golfer
  • You prefer an oversized grip for stability
  • You have a straight or slight arc putting stroke
Skip if
  • You are a right-handed golfer
  • You prefer a standard-sized grip
  • You need a toe-hang design for a strong arc stroke

Verdict: Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black 34" Left Hand offers reliable distance control for left-handed players with a straight or slight arc stroke. The oversized grip and speed-optimized face make it a solid choice for consistency.

3Also great
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 1 Putter

Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 1 Putter

Best for: Straight or slight arc stroke right-handers

Color
Black
Hand Orientation
Right Hand
Club Length
34"
Shaft Length
34"

This Cleveland Golf HB Soft 2 Putter is a 34-inch right-hand model designed for straight or slight arc strokes. It features the UST Mamiya All-In shaft for stability and Speed Optimized Face Technology to normalize ball speed. The black finish and plumber's neck hosel complement its alignment system. You get a consistent swing feel with this specific stroke-type design.

Pros
  • 34-inch shaft length for standard reach
  • UST Mamiya All-In shaft for stability
  • Speed Optimized Face Technology for consistent distance
  • Designed for straight or slight arc strokes
Cons
  • Single size option at 34 inches limits length customization
  • Right-hand orientation excludes left-handed golfers
Good fit if
  • You prefer a 34-inch putter length
  • You use a straight or slight arc putting stroke
  • You want a right-hand black putter
Skip if
  • You need a 35-inch shaft length
  • You are a left-handed golfer
  • You prefer a silver finish over black

Verdict: Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 1 Putter suits right-handed players with straight or slight arc strokes who want a 34-inch black putter with stable shaft feel.

4Also great
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black #10.5P 34"

Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black #10.5P 34"

Best for: straight or slight arc stroke golfers

Color
Black
Hand Orientation
Right Hand
Club Length
34"
Hosel Type
Plumber's Neck
Shaft Length
34"
Dimensions
43 × 5 × 6 inches

This Cleveland Golf HB Soft 2 Black Putter features a 34-inch shaft and a plumber's neck hosel. It uses UST Mamiya All-In shafts for stability and speed-optimized face technology to normalize ball speed. The model is designed for right-handed golfers with straight or slight arc strokes. Its black finish and specific toe hang align with your swing type for consistent distance performance.

Pros
  • UST Mamiya All-In shaft provides advanced stability and consistency
  • Speed-optimized face technology normalizes ball speed across the striking area
  • Plumber's neck hosel suits straight or slight arc stroke types
  • Right-hand orientation matches your grip preference
Cons
  • 34-inch length is shorter than the 35-inch options available in variations
  • Single hosel style limits fitting options compared to other models in the list
  • Fixed 34-inch length excludes taller shaft configurations
Good fit if
  • You prefer a 34-inch shaft length for your putting setup
  • You use a straight or slight arc putting stroke
  • You want a plumber's neck hosel for alignment
Skip if
  • You require a 35-inch shaft length
  • You need a blade or mallet hosel style
  • You play left-handed

Verdict: Cleveland Golf HB Soft 2 Black Putter suits right-handed golfers who prefer a 34-inch plumber's neck putter for straight or slight arc strokes. Its specific hosel and shaft design target consistent distance control for that swing path.

Specifications side by side

SpecCleveland HB Soft 2 Black #11 Putter, 34"Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black 34" PutterCleveland HB Soft 2 Model 1 PutterCleveland HB Soft 2 Black #10.5P 34"
Hand OrientationLeft HandLeft HandRight HandRight Hand
Club Length34"34"34"34"
Hosel TypeSingle BendSingle Bend–Plumber's Neck
Grip TypeOversizedOversized––
ColorBlackBlackBlackBlack
Shaft Length34"34"34"34"
GripOversized GripOversized Grip––
Dimensions43 × 5 × 6 inches43 × 5 × 6 inches–43 × 5 × 6 inches
Weight–––1.2 pounds
Size34"34"34"34"
ModelHB Soft 2 Black #11HB Soft 2 Black Retreve11241631HB Soft 2 Black #10.5P

How to choose the right Cleveland Black Putter

Match hand orientation

Select the putter based on your dominant hand. Left-handed golfers should choose models explicitly labeled for left use, such as the HB Soft 2 Black #11 or the 34" Left Hand version. Right-handed players must select the Model 1 or the #10.5P options. Using the wrong orientation affects your stance and alignment. Ensure the product description confirms your handedness before purchasing to avoid compatibility issues with your natural stroke path.

Check shaft length

Verify the shaft length matches your height and posture. All listed Cleveland HB Soft 2 models in this guide feature a 34-inch shaft. This standard length suits most average-height golfers. If you are taller or shorter, a different length may improve your setup. Consistent length helps maintain a stable eye position over the ball. Compare the 34-inch specification against your current putter to ensure a seamless transition without altering your stance significantly.

Evaluate grip size

Consider the grip diameter for hand stability. The HB Soft 2 Black #11 and the 34" Left Hand model both include an oversized grip. This design reduces hand action and promotes a smoother stroke. Right-handed options like the Model 1 do not list a specific grip type in the data. If you prefer a larger grip for control, stick with the models that explicitly mention this feature. The oversized design aids in reducing wrist breakdown during the putt.

Align with stroke type

Choose the hosel based on your stroke path. The HB Soft 2 Black #11 features a single bend hosel, which supports a straight stroke. The #10.5P model uses a plumber's neck, also suited for straight or slight arc strokes. The 34" Left Hand model offers stability for straight or slight arc paths. Matching the hosel design to your natural stroke path improves consistency. Verify the stroke recommendation in the product details to ensure proper alignment mechanics.

Review color finish

Confirm the putter head color matches your preference. All products in this specific guide share a black color finish. This uniform appearance helps you focus on other critical specs like length and orientation. The black finish provides a consistent visual contrast against the green. Since color is constant across the list, you can prioritize other features like hand orientation and grip size without worrying about aesthetic variations in this selection.

Frequently asked questions

Which Cleveland Golf black putter is best for left-handed golfers?

The Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black #11 Putter is the top choice for left-handed players. It features a single bend hosel that supports a straight stroke. The oversized grip enhances stability and distance control. This model is specifically designed for left-handed golfers who prefer a consistent, straight putting path.

What shaft length do these Cleveland Golf putters have?

All listed Cleveland Golf black putters have a shaft length of 34 inches. This standard length suits most average-height golfers. The consistent length across the HB Soft 2 Black series allows you to find a model that matches your handedness and stroke without adjusting to different sizes.

Are there right-handed options in this Cleveland Golf black putter collection?

Yes, there are right-handed options available. The Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 1 and the HB Soft 2 Black #10.5P are both designed for right-handed golfers. The #10.5P features a plumber's neck hosel, which is ideal for straight or slight arc strokes. Both maintain the 34-inch shaft length.

Do these putters come with oversized grips?

The left-handed models, including the HB Soft 2 Black #11 and the 34" Left Hand version, come with oversized grips. These grips provide added stability and help reduce hand tension during the stroke. The right-handed models listed do not explicitly mention an oversized grip in their specifications.

What type of stroke is best suited for the Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black #10.5P?

The HB Soft 2 Black #10.5P is best for straight or slight arc strokes. Its plumber's neck hosel design promotes a consistent path for this swing type. Right-handed golfers using this stroke will find the shaft and hosel combination supports reliable distance control and accuracy on the green.

How do the dimensions of these putters compare?

Most models share similar dimensions, measuring 5 inches in width and 6 inches in height. The overall length is listed as 43 inches, while the shaft length is 34 inches. The HB Soft 2 Black #10.5P also specifies a weight of 1.2 pounds. These specs help you gauge the head size and feel.

Is there a budget-friendly Cleveland Golf black putter option?

The Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black 34" Left Hand is identified as the best budget option. It offers reliable distance control for left-handed players. The speed-optimized face and oversized grip contribute to its consistency. This model provides solid performance for golfers seeking stability without a premium price point.

See also

How this review was put together

  • Specs are quoted from the Amazon listing, not measured in a lab.
  • The score is out of 10, based on listed specifications and buyer feedback.
  • Prices were read from the listing when this page was last built and move without notice.

2,571 reviews · 1,445 rated products · 87 brands tracked

We earn a commission when you buy through our Amazon links. That never changes a score.

More Putters

See all

Deal alerts

A weekly note when tracked products drop below their usual Amazon price.

Demo form. It is not connected to any mailing list and stores nothing.