Looking Beyond the All Turf Mats 3×5 Super Tee Golf? 6 Alternatives Worth a Look
Review 6 golf mat alternatives to the All Turf Mats 3x5 Super Tee. We compare footprint size, foam thickness, and tee compatibility using only published specifications.
As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You might be searching for all turf mats 3×5 super tee golf alternatives because this mat fits tight spaces but lacks wider coverage. The original model offers a 5' x 3' footprint with a 1-inch thick foam backing. It holds both wooden and rubber tees securely. The nylon face is residue-free and durable. These specs make it ideal for compact garage simulators where floor space is limited.
You may want something else if you need more cushioning or a larger hitting area. The alternatives listed here share overlapping specifications with the original product. They include wider sizes like 5' x 5' or 6' x 5' options. Some provide heavier foam bases for better shock absorption. Others focus on specific features like automatic ball return or modular strip designs. This selection covers different height profiles and weight classes. You can compare these specs to find the right fit for your practice routine.
How alternatives compare to the original
GoSports Elite 5×5 ft Golf Mat
The GoSports Elite 5×5 ft Golf Mat expands your practice area to a full 5' x 5' square. This adds 6 square feet of turf compared to the All Turf Mats 3×5 model. It uses a 15 mm foam base, which is thinner than the 1-inch backing of the original. However, the GoSports unit weighs 26.9 pounds, providing a heavier, more stable platform that resists sliding. You gain a wider hitting zone for wider swings or simulator setups. You give up the specific 1-inch thickness and the dedicated rubber tee holes found in the All Turf Mats version. Choose this if you need a broader, heavier mat for stable footing in a garage.
Ponsonbay 6×5 ft Golf Hitting Mat
The Ponsonbay 6×5 ft Golf Hitting Mat offers a significantly larger 6' x 5' footprint. This provides 12 square feet of turf, doubling the coverage of the original 5' x 3' mat. It features a 1.22-inch height, which is slightly thicker than the original's 1-inch profile. The Ponsonbay includes fixed tee heights and ball storage, features the original does not list. You gain organized practice space and consistent tee positions. You give up the specific shock-absorbent closed-cell foam backing and the residue-free Nylon turf claim of the All Turf Mats. Select this if you want a larger, organized setup for dedicated practice sessions rather than a compact simulator insert.
Perfect Practice Chipping Net & Mat
The Perfect Practice Chipping Net & Mat is not a full hitting mat. It measures 48 inches by 49.6 inches and weighs only 7.5 pounds. This is much lighter than the All Turf Mats 3×5 model. It is designed specifically for chipping practice with an automatic ball return system. You gain a dedicated tool for short-game precision and space-saving convenience. You give up the ability to drive or hit full shots on a large turf surface. The original offers a 5' x 3' area for full swings. Choose this if you want a compact, specialized device for chipping drills indoors, not a replacement for a full-size hitting mat.
GoSports 12 x 6 ft Simulator Turf
The GoSports 12 x 6 ft Simulator Turf is an unpadded strip measuring 150 inches by 72 inches. It is much longer and wider than the original 5' x 3' mat. It lacks the 1-inch foam backing, offering only a 0.59-inch height. This model weighs 40.1 pounds, providing a heavy, stable base for simulator setups. You gain a realistic grass feel and modular width for large simulator bays. You give up the built-in shock absorption and the specific tee-holding features of the All Turf Mats. Pick this if you need a wide, unpadded turf strip for a custom simulator build, rather than a standalone, cushioned practice mat.
Bearwill 5x5ft 31mm Golf Mat
The Bearwill 5x5ft 31mm Golf Mat matches the All Turf Mats in width but doubles the length to 5' x 5'. It offers a 31mm profile, which is thicker than the original's 1-inch backing. The Bearwill weighs 20.7 pounds, offering a solid, heavy build for backyard use. You gain a larger, square hitting area and robust impact absorption for heavy swings. You give up the specific commercial-grade Nylon face pile and the residue-free cleaning claim of the original. Choose this if you prioritize a standard square footprint and heavy-duty construction for outdoor driving practice over the specific tee-holding features of the All Turf Mats model.
The Indoor Golf Shop SIGPRO Softy XL
The Indoor Golf Shop SIGPRO Softy XL is a specialized hitting strip, not a full mat. It measures 4' x 1', making it much narrower than the original 5' x 3' mat. It features a 2.63-inch height, which is significantly thicker than the original's 1-inch backing. This model is designed as an insert for larger simulator setups. You gain enhanced joint protection and precise turf feedback in a replaceable zone. You give up the full practice area and standalone usability of the All Turf Mats. Select this if you need a shock-absorbing insert for a custom simulator, rather than a complete, self-contained hitting mat for general practice.
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | All Turf Mats 3×5 Super Tee Golf Mat Best overall | compact indoor simulators and tee practice | |
| 2 | GoSports Elite 5×5 ft Golf Mat Also great | Compact home practice with stable footing | |
| 3 | Ponsonbay 6×5 ft Golf Hitting Mat Best budget | Golfers wanting fixed tee heights and ball storage | |
| 4 | Perfect Practice Chipping Net & Mat Best premium | indoor chipping practice and ball return | |
| 5 | GoSports 12 x 6 ft Simulator Turf Also great | wide simulator turf strips | |
| 6 | Bearwill 5x5ft 31mm Golf Mat Best backyard | backyard driving practice with heavy swings | |
| 7 | The Indoor Golf Shop SIGPRO Softy XL Also great | indoor simulator hitting strips |
All Turf Mats 3×5 Super Tee Golf Mat
Best for: compact indoor simulators and tee practice
- Dimensions
- 5' x 3'
- Color
- Green
- Use
- Indoor
This 5 x 3 foot hitting mat uses a 1-inch dense Nylon face pile to hold wooden and rubber tees securely. A 5/8-inch closed-cell foam backing provides shock absorption and slip resistance. The commercial-grade turf is UV-resistant and colorfast, making it suitable for indoor simulators or outdoor ranges. It is designed for players who need a durable, residue-free surface for driver and iron practice.
- 1-inch Nylon face pile holds wooden and rubber tees
- 5/8-inch closed-cell foam backing for shock absorption
- Commercial-grade Nylon turf is UV and weather resistant
- Residue-free surface protects clubface grooves
- Made in the USA in Dalton, Georgia
- 5 x 3 foot dimensions are smaller than the 5 x 5 foot options available from competitors
- 1-inch height is thinner than the 15 mm or 31 mm mats listed in this guide
- You have limited space and need a compact 3 x 5 foot footprint
- You want a mat that securely holds both wooden and rubber tees
- You prefer a thinner 1-inch profile for stable ball flight on simulators
- You need a wider 5 x 5 foot or larger hitting area
- You prefer a thicker mat with 15 mm or more of cushioning
- You want an octagon shape rather than a standard rectangle
Verdict: All Turf Mats 3×5 Super Tee Golf Mat fits players who prioritize a compact, durable surface for precise tee placement over maximum cushioning or wide coverage. It is ideal for garage simulators where space is tight.
GoSports Elite 5×5 ft Golf Mat
Best for: Compact home practice with stable footing
- Color
- Green
- Intended Use
- Indoor and Outdoor
- Size
- 5×5 ft
- Dimensions
- 60 × 60 × 0.59 inches
- Weight
- 26.9 pounds
This GoSports hitting mat measures 5 x 5 feet with a 15 mm thick EVA foam base. The 0.59 inch height provides shock absorption to reduce joint strain. It features eight integrated tee holes and includes three rubber tees. The 26.9 pound weight helps keep the mat stable. It suits golfers practicing indoors or outdoors who need a durable, consistent surface for various clubs.
- 5 x 5 ft octagon surface area
- 15 mm EVA foam base for shock absorption
- Eight integrated tee holes for multiple setups
- 26.9 lb weight for stability
- Includes three rubber tees of varying heights
- Heavier at 26.9 pounds compared to lighter alternatives
- Smaller 5 x 5 ft footprint than 12 x 6 ft simulator mats
- Octagon shape offers less rectangular turf space than standard squares
- You want a stable mat that resists sliding during swings
- You prefer a compact 5 x 5 ft size for limited spaces
- You need integrated tee holes for quick setup changes
- You require a full 12 x 6 ft simulator turf area
- You need a lightweight mat for frequent transport
- You prefer a standard rectangular shape over an octagon
Verdict: GoSports Elite 5×5 Octagon Golf Mat delivers stable practice with its heavy 26.9 lb build and 15 mm foam base. It fits golfers who value a compact, durable surface for home or garage use rather than large simulator setups.
Ponsonbay 6×5 ft Golf Hitting Mat
Best for: Golfers wanting fixed tee heights and ball storage
- Color
- Green
- Intended Use
- Indoor and Outdoor, Driving, Chipping
- Dimensions
- 72 × 60 × 1.22 inches
The Ponsonbay D224 is a 6 by 5 foot hitting mat with a 1.22 inch thick EVA foam base. It includes a built-in tray for up to 100 balls and three fixed tee heights. You get a large practice surface for indoor or outdoor use. The integrated ball storage keeps your setup organized. This mat suits golfers who want a complete practice station with shock absorption and fixed tee positions.
- Built-in tray holds up to 100 golf balls
- 1.22 inch thick EVA foam base for shock absorption
- Three fixed rubber tee heights (2.4, 2.8, 3.1 inches)
- Large 6 by 5 foot practice surface
- Fixed tee heights do not adjust to your preference
- Mat thickness is 1.22 inches, thinner than the Bearwill 31mm option
- You want a built-in tray to hold up to 100 balls
- You prefer fixed tee heights for consistent practice
- You need a large 6 by 5 foot surface for full swings
- You need adjustable tee heights for different ball positions
- You want a thicker mat than 1.22 inches for maximum joint protection
- You prefer a smaller footprint for compact storage
Verdict: Ponsonbay 6×5 ft Integrated Hitting Mat provides a large practice area with convenient ball storage and fixed tee heights. It fits golfers who value organized setups and consistent tee positions over adjustable features.
Perfect Practice Chipping Net & Mat
Best for: indoor chipping practice and ball return
- Target Type
- Three target pockets
- Ball Return
- Gravity feed
- Included Accessories
- Chipping mat
- Features
- Automatic Ball Return
- Color
- Green
- Target Audience
- Men
This is a gravity-feed chipping net with a 48-inch length and 49.6-inch width. It includes a green chipping mat and three target pockets. The unit weighs 7.5 pounds and stands 196 inches tall. It suits you if you want a compact indoor aid for short-game repetition. The automatic ball return helps you focus on form without retrieving shots.
- Gravity-feed automatic ball return
- Three distinct target pockets
- Includes green chipping mat
- Lightweight 7.5-pound design
- 196-inch height limits low-ceiling rooms
- Smaller footprint than 5×5 ft mats
- Intended for chipping only
- You practice chipping indoors frequently
- You want automatic ball retrieval
- You need a lightweight travel aid
- You need a full hitting mat
- You have very low ceilings
- You practice driving only
Verdict: Perfect Practice PP61580 Chipping Net fits you if you want a dedicated, space-saving tool for short-game precision. It is not a substitute for a full-size hitting mat.
GoSports 12 x 6 ft Simulator Turf
Best for: wide simulator turf strips
- Dimensions
- 12 x 6 ft
- Included Accessories
- Carpet tape
- Color
- Green
- Intended Use
- Simulator, Indoor and Outdoor
- Weight
- 40.1 pounds
This GoSports turf measures 12 by 6 feet with a 15 mm pile height. It weighs 40.1 pounds and uses carpet tape for installation. The unpadded synthetic surface dampens ball rebounds to reduce ricochets. You should use this mat if you need a wide, commercial-grade strip for a simulator setup. It fits well under hitting nets or enclosures.
- 12 by 6 feet width covers 72 inches of space
- 15 mm elite turf pile height mimics real grass
- Unpadded design keeps weight at 40.1 pounds
- Includes carpet tape for securing to hard floors
- Unpadded construction offers less cushion than padded variants
- 12 feet length is shorter than 15 feet options
- Requires separate purchase of hitting mats for protection
- You need a wide turf strip for a simulator enclosure
- You want to secure turf to concrete or wood floors
- You prefer a commercial-grade synthetic surface
- You require a padded hitting surface
- You need a turf wider than 12 feet
- You want a complete mat with built-in padding
Verdict: GoSports 12×6 ft Unpadded Simulator Turf provides a wide, stable base for simulator setups. It suits players who prioritize a realistic grass feel and modular width over built-in cushioning.
Bearwill 5x5ft 31mm Golf Mat
Best for: backyard driving practice with heavy swings
- Color
- Green
- Intended Use
- Simulator, Backyard, Practice, Driving
- Size
- 5×5 ft
- Dimensions
- 60 × 60 × 1.22 inches
- Weight
- 20.7 pounds
The Bearwill 5x5ft Golf Mat measures 60 by 60 inches with a 1.22-inch profile. It combines 16mm synthetic turf with a 15mm EVA base for impact absorption. This setup suits backyard or indoor practice. The mat supports driving and simulator use. It features six tee positions for both left- and right-handed players. You get a stable surface for repeated swings.
- 31mm total thickness from 16mm turf and 15mm EVA base
- 5×5 ft hitting area with six tee positions
- Rated for 150,000 hits
- Anti-slip bottom for stability on uneven ground
- 20.7 pounds weight makes it heavier than thinner mats
- 1.22-inch height is lower than 15mm premium options
- You want a durable mat for heavy driving practice
- You need a square 5×5 ft area for simulator use
- You prefer a thick 31mm profile for joint protection
- You need a larger 12×6 ft simulator turf
- You require a lighter mat for frequent transport
- You want a non-slip octagon shape
Verdict: Bearwill 5x5ft Golf Mat 31mm provides a robust 31mm profile for backyard driving practice. It fits golfers prioritizing impact absorption and a standard square hitting area.
The Indoor Golf Shop SIGPRO Softy XL
Best for: indoor simulator hitting strips
- Dimensions
- 4' x 1'
- Color
- Green
- Intended Use
- Simulator
The SIGPRO Softy XL Hitting Strip is a 4-foot by 1-foot replaceable turf insert designed for indoor golf simulator setups. It features a 2.63-inch height with a plush 1-inch Teeline turf surface that mimics real grass. The strip includes shock-absorbing foam and compression slots to reduce joint vibration. You should consider this option if you need a targeted hitting area that fits within a larger mat base, allowing for precise feedback and easy replacement of worn sections.
- Replaceable design allows you to refresh worn turf without buying a new mat
- 2.63-inch total height provides deep cushioning for joint protection
- 12-inch width accommodates real tees for authentic swing practice
- Shock-absorbing foam insert reduces harsh vibrations on impact
- 12-inch width is narrower than the 60-inch width of the GoSports 12×6 ft Simulator Turf
- 4-foot length is shorter than the 5-foot length of the GoSports Elite and Bearwill mats
- Single strip footprint covers less total area than the 5×5 ft GoSports and Bearwill options
- You already own a large simulator mat and want a replaceable hitting zone
- You prioritize joint comfort and shock absorption during repetitive indoor practice
- You want to use real tees for accurate launch monitor feedback
- You need a standalone mat that covers your entire hitting area without additional base gear
- You prefer a wider hitting surface that accommodates multiple stance positions
- You want a complete mat solution rather than a replaceable insert
Verdict: SIGPRO Softy XL Hitting Strip is a specialized insert for golfers who need a replaceable, shock-absorbing zone within a larger simulator setup. It fits you best if you value joint protection and precise turf feedback over a full standalone mat footprint.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | All Turf Mats 3×5 Super Tee Golf Mat | GoSports Elite 5×5 ft Golf Mat | Ponsonbay 6×5 ft Golf Hitting Mat | Perfect Practice Chipping Net & Mat | GoSports 12 x 6 ft Simulator Turf | Bearwill 5x5ft 31mm Golf Mat | The Indoor Golf Shop SIGPRO Softy XL |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dimensions | 5' x 3' | – | – | – | 12 x 6 ft | – | 4' x 1' |
| Target Type | – | – | – | Three target pockets | – | – | – |
| Ball Return | – | – | – | Gravity feed | – | – | – |
| Included Accessories | – | – | – | Chipping mat | Carpet tape | – | – |
| Features | – | – | – | Automatic Ball Return | – | – | – |
| Color | Green | Green | Green | Green | Green | Green | Green |
| Intended Use | – | Indoor and Outdoor | Indoor and Outdoor, Driving, Chipping | Chipping | Simulator, Indoor and Outdoor | Simulator, Backyard, Practice, Driving | Simulator |
| Target Audience | – | – | – | Men | – | – | – |
| Size | 5' x 3' (L x W) | 5×5 ft | 6' x 5' (L x W) | – | 12 x 6 ft Simulator Turf, Unpadded | 5×5 ft | 4' x 1' (L x W) |
| Use | Indoor | Indoor, Outdoor | Indoor, Outdoor | Indoor | Indoor, Outdoor | Indoor, Outdoor | Indoor |
| Weight | – | 26.9 pounds | – | 7.5 pounds | 40.1 pounds | 20.7 pounds | – |
| Model | – | GOLF-MAT-15-5×5-OCT | D224 | PP61580 SKU 24679745 | GOLF-TURF-15-12X6 | Golf Mat 5' x 5' | – |
Frequently asked questions
Which golf mat offers the largest hitting surface?
The GoSports 12 x 6 ft Simulator Turf provides the widest area. It measures 150 inches in length and 72 inches in width. This unpadded strip suits players who want a realistic grass feel for simulator setups. It weighs 40.1 pounds, offering a stable base for wide swings without built-in cushioning.
What is the thickest golf mat available?
The Bearwill 5x5ft Golf Mat features the thickest profile at 1.22 inches. This 31mm height is designed for heavy swings and backyard driving practice. It prioritizes impact absorption over other features. The mat weighs 20.7 pounds and provides a standard square hitting area for robust practice sessions.
Are there mats with fixed tee heights?
Yes, the Ponsonbay 6×5 ft Integrated Hitting Mat includes fixed tee heights. This model helps golfers maintain consistent tee positions during practice. It also offers convenient ball storage for an organized setup. The mat measures 72 inches by 60 inches with a 1.22-inch thickness for a large practice area.
Is there a specialized mat for chipping practice?
The Perfect Practice Chipping Net & Mat is designed specifically for short-game precision. It features an automatic ball return system to save time. This unit is not a substitute for a full-size hitting mat. It measures 48 inches by 49.6 inches and weighs only 7.5 pounds for easy indoor storage.
Which mat is best for joint protection in simulators?
The SIGPRO Softy XL Hitting Strip focuses on shock absorption for joint protection. It is a specialized insert measuring 48 inches by 12 inches with a 2.63-inch height. This strip fits within larger simulator setups to provide precise turf feedback. It is ideal for indoor use where replaceable zones are valued.
What is the lightest golf mat on the list?
The Perfect Practice Chipping Net & Mat is the lightest option at 7.5 pounds. This low weight makes it easy to move for indoor chipping practice. It measures 48 inches by 49.6 inches. Unlike heavier turf mats, this net focuses on ball return and space-saving design for short-game training.
Can I use these mats outdoors?
Several options support outdoor use. The GoSports Elite 5×5 ft Golf Mat is rated for indoor and outdoor environments. The Ponsonbay 6×5 ft Hitting Mat also works for both settings. The Bearwill mat is suitable for backyard driving. The GoSports 12×6 ft turf strip is designed for indoor and outdoor simulator use.
Which mat is best for compact home simulators?
The All Turf Mats 3×5 Super Tee Golf Mat is ideal for tight spaces. It measures 60 inches by 36 inches with a 1-inch thick foam backing. This compact size fits garage simulators where space is limited. It supports precise tee placement for both wooden and rubber tees.
See also
How this review was put together
- Specs are quoted from the Amazon listing, not measured in a lab.
- The score is out of 10, based on listed specifications and buyer feedback.
- Prices were read from the listing when this page was last built and move without notice.
1,119 reviews · 1,445 rated products · 87 brands tracked
We earn a commission when you buy through our Amazon links. That never changes a score.
