Durbles or The Indoor Golf Shop? Golf Hitting Nets Compared in 2026
Compare Durbles and The Indoor Golf Shop hitting nets. We analyze surface area, thickness, and design to help you pick the best mat for your space.
As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
When you compare durbles vs the indoor golf shop golf hitting net options, you are looking at two distinct approaches to practice. Both products aim to provide a realistic turf feel for indoor and outdoor use. The primary difference lies in their design philosophy. One offers a complete, stable platform with a large hitting surface. The other provides a specialized, replaceable strip for targeted practice. Your choice depends on whether you need a full mat or a modular insert.
Size
5' x 4'
4' x 1'
Height
1.5 inches
2.63 inches
Weight
7.72 pounds
not listed
Replaceability
not listed
Replaceable hitting strip
Included Accessories
Adjustable tee and 10 real golf tees
not listed
Choose the first if
- You want a complete, standalone mat with a large 5x4ft hitting area.
- You prefer a lower profile at 1.5 inches height for standard setups.
- You need a product that includes tees and an adjustable tee holder.
Choose the second if
- You need a modular insert that can be replaced when worn.
- You prefer a taller, 2.63-inch profile for deeper cushioning.
- You are building a simulator setup that requires a specific 4x1ft strip.
Verdict
Choose the Durbles mat if you need a comprehensive, all-in-one practice solution with a generous surface area. Select The Indoor Golf Shop SIGPRO if you require a specialized, replaceable strip with greater height for specific simulator configurations.
Mat Size and Thickness Comparison
Surface Coverage Area
Edge: Durbles 5x4ft 38mm Golf Hitting Mat
You get a significantly larger practice surface with the Durbles option. It measures 5 feet by 4 feet, giving you 20 square feet of hitting area. This wide footprint allows you to practice various stances and swing paths comfortably. The Indoor Golf Shop strip is much narrower. It measures 4 feet by 1 foot, providing only 4 square feet of turf. This strip is designed to be an insert for a larger mat system. If you need a standalone mat for full swings, the Durbles size is more practical. The smaller footprint of the SIGPRO strip requires a separate base mat to be useful.
Mat Thickness and Cushioning
Edge: The Indoor Golf Shop SIGPRO Softy XL
The Durbles mat stands at 1.5 inches thick. It uses a high-density EVA foam base to absorb shock. This thickness protects your wrists and joints during repetitive practice sessions. The Indoor Golf Shop strip is thicker at 2.63 inches. It features a super soft foam insert with compression release slots. This design aims to eliminate harsh vibrations and provide a plush feel. The extra height of the SIGPRO strip may offer superior joint protection for some golfers. However, the Durbles thickness is sufficient for standard shock absorption. Both products prioritize comfort, but they achieve it through different structural designs.
Included Accessories
Edge: Durbles 5x4ft 38mm Golf Hitting Mat
Durbles provides a more complete starter kit right out of the box. It includes the 5x4ft hitting surface, a pre-drilled hole, a sturdy adjustable tee, and ten real golf tees. You can set it up instantly without buying extra parts. The Indoor Golf Shop SIGPRO strip does not list any included accessories. It is sold as a replaceable hitting strip component. You would need to source your own tees and potentially a base mat separately. For buyers who want an all-inclusive solution, the Durbles package offers immediate usability. The SIGPRO strip is better suited for those already owning a compatible base system.
Turf Quality and Feel
Edge: Tie
Both products use green artificial turf to mimic real fairways. Durbles uses a country club style turf that allows the use of real golf tees anywhere on the surface. It aims to provide authentic divot feedback and natural swing rhythm. The Indoor Golf Shop uses Teeline golf turf on its strip. This turf is designed to mimic legendary courses like Augusta and Pinehurst. It also supports real tees and provides accurate feedback for launch monitors. Both claim to offer premium on-course feels. The Durbles turf covers a wider area, while the SIGPRO turf is part of a specialized insert. Your preference depends on whether you value broad coverage or specialized insert performance.
Portability and Weight
Edge: Tie
The Durbles mat weighs 7.72 pounds. Its 5x4ft size and foam base make it a substantial piece of equipment. It stays firmly in place on hardwood, concrete, or outdoor grass due to its anti-slip backing. This stability is good for vigorous practice but limits easy transport. The weight and dimensions of the Indoor Golf Shop strip are not explicitly listed in the provided data. However, as a replaceable strip, it is likely lighter and easier to swap out. If you need to move your practice setup frequently, the strip system may offer more flexibility. The Durbles mat is designed for a fixed, stable practice location.
Which golf mat fits your space
Golfer needing wide practice area
Our pick: Durbles 5x4ft 38mm Golf Hitting Mat
The Durbles mat offers a 5 by 4 foot surface. This 20 square foot area lets you practice different stances and swing paths comfortably. The 38 millimeter thickness provides shock absorption for your wrists. You get a stable base with anti-slip backing. This large footprint is ideal for full swings in larger rooms.
Simulator user with limited space
Our pick: The Indoor Golf Shop SIGPRO Softy XL
The SIGPRO Softy XL measures 4 feet by 1 foot. This strip fits neatly into compact simulator setups. It features a replaceable hitting strip design. You can refresh worn areas without buying a new mat. The 2.63 inch height and foam insert protect your joints during repetitive practice sessions.
Golfer wanting replaceable components
Our pick: The Indoor Golf Shop SIGPRO Softy XL
The Indoor Golf Shop strip is designed for replacement. You can swap out the worn hitting strip instead of discarding the entire mat. This feature supports long-term use. The strip mimics real fairway grass. It provides accurate feedback for launch monitors. This approach is cost-effective for maintaining your practice surface over time.
Durbles 5x4ft 38mm Golf Hitting Mat
Best for: players wanting thick shock absorption and a large hitting area
- Color
- Green
- Intended Use
- Simulator, Indoor and Outdoor, Backyard, Driving
- Dimensions
- 60 × 48 × 1.5 inches
- Weight
- 7.72 pounds
The Durbles 5x4ft golf mat measures 60 by 48 inches with a 38mm thick surface. It features a shock-absorbing EVA foam base to protect your joints during practice. The green turf includes a pre-drilled hole and comes with an adjustable tee and ten real golf tees. This setup suits indoor simulators or outdoor backyard driving ranges where you need a stable, tee-able surface.
- 38mm high-density artificial grass thickness
- Shock-absorbing EVA foam base
- Includes 10 real golf tees and adjustable tee
- Anti-slip backing for stability
- 5x4ft large hitting surface
- Heavier 7.72-pound build compared to lighter mats
- Fixed 5x4ft size limits portability
- Single 38mm thickness option
- You want a thick, shock-absorbing surface for joint protection
- You need a large 5x4ft area for full swings
- You prefer a stable mat that stays in place on hard floors
- You need a mat smaller than 5x4ft for tight spaces
- You prefer a lightweight mat under 5 pounds
- You want a mat with multiple thickness options
Verdict: Durbles 5x4ft 38mm Golf Mat offers a thick, stable surface ideal for players prioritizing joint protection and a large hitting area. It fits best in dedicated indoor or outdoor practice spots where weight is not a concern.
The Indoor Golf Shop SIGPRO Softy XL
Best for: Replacing worn turf on compatible simulator mats
- Dimensions
- 4' x 1'
- Color
- Green
- Intended Use
- Simulator
This replaceable hitting strip measures 48 inches long and 12 inches wide. It stands 2.63 inches high with a plush 1-inch Teeline turf surface. The design includes a shock-absorbing foam insert and three compression release slots to reduce joint impact. You can use real tees with this indoor simulator mat insert. It fits over compatible base mats for a durable, authentic practice surface.
- Replaceable strip design refreshes worn areas without replacing the whole mat
- 48-inch length provides extended coverage for indoor practice
- Shock-absorbing foam insert protects joints from vibration
- Three compression release slots enhance flexibility and comfort
- 12-inch width is narrower than standard 4-foot mats
- 2.63-inch height is taller than the 1.25-inch variation option
- Requires a compatible base mat for full installation
- You want to replace only the worn turf surface
- You need a strip that accommodates real tees
- You prioritize shock absorption for joint comfort
- You need a complete standalone mat without a base
- You prefer a wider 4-foot hitting surface
- You want the thinnest possible profile for low ceilings
Verdict: The Indoor Golf Shop SIGPRO Softy XL offers a durable, shock-absorbing surface for indoor simulators. It suits golfers who want to refresh their hitting area without buying a new base mat.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Durbles 5x4ft 38mm Golf Hitting Mat | The Indoor Golf Shop SIGPRO Softy XL |
|---|---|---|
| Dimensions | – | 4' x 1' |
| Color | Green | Green |
| Intended Use | Simulator, Indoor and Outdoor, Backyard, Driving | Simulator |
| Use | Indoor, Outdoor | Indoor |
| Weight | 7.72 pounds | – |
| Size | 5' x 4' (L x W) | 4' x 1' (L x W) |
Frequently asked questions
What is the main difference between the Durbles mat and the SIGPRO Softy XL?
The Durbles mat is a standalone 5 by 4 foot unit designed for broad practice areas. It provides a complete surface with 38 millimeter thickness for shock absorption. The SIGPRO Softy XL is a 4 by 1 foot strip intended to replace worn turf on existing simulator mats. You should choose the Durbles option for a full new hitting area. Select the SIGPRO product only if you need to refresh a compatible base mat.
Which golf mat provides better shock absorption for joint protection?
The Durbles 5x4ft mat offers superior shock absorption due to its 38 millimeter or 1.5 inch height. This thick profile cushions your joints during impact. The SIGPRO Softy XL has a height of 2.63 inches, which is also substantial. However, the Durbles design integrates this thickness into a larger, stable surface. You get better overall protection with the Durbles mat if you prioritize a cushioned feel across a wide hitting zone.
How much space does the Durbles golf mat require?
The Durbles mat requires a footprint of 5 feet by 4 feet. This equals 20 square feet of space. It weighs 7.72 pounds, so it is stable but heavy. You need enough room to accommodate this large surface area comfortably. The SIGPRO Softy XL is much smaller at 4 by 1 foot. It occupies only 4 square feet. Choose the Durbles option if you have ample floor space for a full practice setup.
Can I use the Durbles mat for outdoor practice?
Yes, the Durbles mat is intended for both indoor and outdoor use. The product data lists it as suitable for backyard and driving range scenarios. Its green color helps it blend with outdoor environments. The SIGPRO Softy XL is designed for indoor simulator use only. If you plan to hit balls outside in your yard or driveway, the Durbles mat is the versatile choice that handles various weather conditions.
Is the SIGPRO Softy XL a complete hitting mat?
No, the SIGPRO Softy XL is not a complete standalone mat. It measures 4 feet by 1 foot and is designed to replace worn turf on compatible simulator mats. You must already have a base mat to use it effectively. The Durbles mat is a complete 5 by 4 foot unit. You can place it directly on the floor. Buy the SIGPRO product only if you need to refresh an existing setup.
Which mat is better for practicing different stances?
The Durbles mat is better for practicing various stances. Its 5 by 4 foot surface provides 20 square feet of hitting area. This wide footprint allows you to adjust your position freely. The SIGPRO Softy XL offers only 4 square feet of space. It is too narrow for diverse stance adjustments. You need the larger Durbles mat if you want to practice drives and different swing paths comfortably.
What are the dimensions of the SIGPRO Softy XL?
The SIGPRO Softy XL measures 48 inches in length and 12 inches in width. This equals a 4 by 1 foot size. Its height is 2.63 inches. The Durbles mat is significantly larger at 60 inches by 48 inches. It also has a height of 1.5 inches. The SIGPRO strip is much narrower and shorter. It is designed for specific replacement needs rather than general practice.
Does the Durbles mat come in other colors?
The available data lists the Durbles mat in Green only. It does not mention other color options for this specific model. The SIGPRO Softy XL is also listed as Green. Both products match standard turf aesthetics. You cannot choose a different color for the Durbles mat based on the current specifications. The green finish helps the mat blend with indoor simulator environments or outdoor backyards.
See also
How this review was put together
- Specs are quoted from the Amazon listing, not measured in a lab.
- The score is out of 10, based on listed specifications and buyer feedback.
- Prices were read from the listing when this page was last built and move without notice.
1,119 reviews · 1,445 rated products · 87 brands tracked
We earn a commission when you buy through our Amazon links. That never changes a score.
